Another look at the Tories’ fortunes through the lens of the Magic The Gathering trading card game.
At end of play, we found out that a single person will put Labour to flight later on in the autumn. Since the card was from the blue suit – suggesting to me a Conservative figure – we now have to see whether at the same time as trying to chart the Tories’ progress through the summer – choppy waters and all – we can flesh out the “Vodalian Mage” who turned up. I don’t feel this is Cameron – he is vulnerable and does not surprise many people these days, and is too immersed in the system to be too dangerous any more, particularly as Pluto has left the talkative, idealistic and somewhat vapid sign of Sagittarius (no disrespect to any Sagittarians out there – my Moon, and that of Owlperson, is in Sagittarius itself) into the earthy and more direct sign of Capricorn, guaranteeing some sort of flashpoint over the course of the next few years. This astrological symbolism is measured in years – from 2009 to 2024 – but Pluto’s move into Capricorn only solidified political battles which have hitherto found little ability to root themselves in anything approaching fine loam and sprout roots. Pluto has been in Sagittarius since 1995, which roughly coincides with the end of the period in which bigger more intense battles were fought elsewhere over ideological substance, and the beginning of the recent phase marked by words speaking larger than actions – the so-called threat from terrorism which did culminate in 9/11 but then turned out to be a paper tiger as regards the real danger to the West. The credit crunch has had an impact – Pluto moving into Capricorn – but Pluto in Sagittarius failed to produce any serious challenge to the western status quo which the Soviet Union embodied during the period of Pluto in Scorpio and before.
As I begin to understand astrology better (and I have an interesting article still to write on my research into electoral fraud, the last election, and astrological predictions for it; I think this also has to do with the Vodalian Mage or the person I think it is) I will write a bit more, but the Tories deserve as much scrutiny as Labour do. So without further verbiage...
PART 2: THE CONSERVATIVE PARTY
Situation
Wing Storm: Sorcery
A thousand wings beating as one can choke the sky itself.
I think the Conservative Party here is choking itself by the number of voices it is trying to speak in and the number of people it is trying to appease. Though it keeps airborne, it may have peaked and gone over with itself damaged by the expenses scandal; though this may hurt the government more at the moment, it will drag the Tories down if they begin to choke themselves because of it. I am drawn to the picture, which shows an old man elf defending himself against a storm, against perhaps death by a thousand cuts. An overwhelming barrage might just help, but it is no substitute for sorting their own selves out and then focussing on barraging the government coherently and with suitable weight behind their words.
Opposing Forces
Svyelunite Priest: Creature – Merfolk
“Early Vodalians worshipped Svyelun, goddess of the Pearl Moon. Later, she became a more abstract figure.” – Sarpadian Empires, vol V.
Here we have the weight of tradition and of history preying on the Tories and holding them back. It is not so much inertia but the difficulties of coming across as a genuine alternative to current chaos rather than being seen as part of it. We have a reference to Vodalia, which although a minor part of the Magic universe is the homeland of our elusive Mage. In opposition to the current party is not good – the Vodalian Mage will work for the Party eventually but he is currently not “of” the party, confirming my suspicion he is not Cameron himself. The more general reading for this card is the stagnation and mindlessness of what the Tories have to put out, and their reliance on abstraction than on concrete momentum to match the times.
Public appearance
Deep Spawn: Creature – Homarid
The Homarids are cousins to Merfolk, in this specific set (“Fallen Empires”, published in 1994 and one of the early game expansions), a race of lobster-men. The card has the ability to evade what is going on at the moment, to stop themselves being the targets of people who would otherwise be targeting it as part of the problem. In a sense the benefit of the doubt is still with the Tories. It could change, however, as we move further on.
Inner realities
Homarid Warrior: Creature – Homarid Warrior
Again, the party believes it is canny enough to evade the public’s wrath, leaving Labour to suffer at their hands. I’m not sure – and neither is Owlperson – how long this will last but the party at least conforms to public appearance, suggesting that people are seeing the reality of a political issue for once in a very long time.
Roots of current situation
Vodalian Soldiers: Creature – Merfolk Warrior
“You think you know everything there is to know about battle? You know orc droppings! Underwater combat is three dimensional. Those thrice-damned Vodalians don’t attack in ranks; they attack in schools.” Irva Jursdotter, pp David Cameron
Another few words from the wise Irva Jursdotter. Here the Vodalians represent the way in which the Tories believed that they would escape from the phase we have entered without much harm and they would be able to take on all comers over their own deep issues here. But when the situation becomes as three-dimensional as it has – and by that I mean that people begin to act in genuine dismay rather than as manipulative as the era of Pluto in Sagittarius has been – there are only winners when people seize the moment and take their rulers – and the so-called Opposition – to task. This is when the problems start – it is up to the party now to solve the issues involved without losing their own momentum – such as it ever was – towards government. Vodalia is not necessarily in opposition to the rest of the party here – the card is not in a negative or ill-dignified aspect – but on the other hand the Tories were in the main taken by surprise when the expenses scandal broke and thus are worthy of a slightly less positive reading to this card at the moment.
Seeds sown by current situation
Grinning Ignus: Creature – Elemental
“Take care what you offer the ignus. Food, perhaps. Coins. But nothing flammable!” – Stovic, village eccentric.
The Tories end this section of the traditional “cross” with a warning – try not to fan the flames of the expenses scandal or its aftermath, particularly not by machinating against the new Speaker for petty party political reasons. Otherwise their house might catch fire too. In other words, a standard “sow the wind, reap the whirlwind” warning.
Existing resources
Ogre Leadfoot: Creature – Ogre
When the goblins need more scrap for the Great Furnace, they simply let the ogres loose and follow in their wake.
Again, here we have the Tories unleashing a storm hoping that it will damage Labour more than it does them. A consequence of Pluto in Sagittarius is that words often speak louder than actions; and this may have lead the Tories to believe over successive leaderships that the way back into government merely means shouting louder than their opponents. As in the Boris spread, this suggests also that they are using someone else to further their own ideas rather than taking control and directing the forces at work. They may believe this worked for Tony Blair over the year of 1996, where successive complaints regarding society as a whole – such as the Dunblane petition and Snowdrop Appeal – went through the Labour Party. However this is repeating here as farce as the Tories try to manipulate their limited policy means into a way of making capital out of nothing, or even out of a negative situation which embroiled them too. Clumsy use of existing resources, in other ways, which has the potential to get out of control and wreck them quite spectacularly.
Personnel Issues
Clockspinning: Instant
A way of manipulating things which is more controlled but again expensive to sustain or repeat and ultimately – pardon Owlperson’s French when he says this – “pissing into the wind”. (Owlie: politics makes us all speak in language which would be otherwise unacceptable to any serious commentator; witness Bob Crowe’s use of language which required multiple asterisks on the front page of the Metro during the Tube strike.) The Tories are trying to put the clock forward to desperately protect – and perhaps remove – those of them that look particularly vulnerable. Again, a suggestion of desperation and it also seems that they too fear the Vodalian Mage, if Owlie’s interpretation of why they would want to have an election – or to put the clock forward on personnel issues – is correct. He also dares to say that this is better than tarot as it is more obvious to me what is going on in which position, and again confirms Cameron too knows – at least subconsciously – who the Vodalian Mage is.
Issues with the new Speaker
Fatal Attraction: Enchantment – Aura
Not one they would like to have seen, but perhaps they can still use him themselves, or use the situation to really prop themselves up – with the constant danger that their machinations against him smack of the inability to settle down and let things get back to normal. Bercow’s appointment has thoroughly annoyed them and has earned him enmity from all quarters of the party – Owlperson says this is partly justified, but the way in which these plots have been made public is symptomatic of why the Tories cannot really be in the position yet to govern the country in everyone’s interests. The party and Bercow will come to blows, and this will not be pleasant for either the Speaker or the Conservative leadership. A situation best left alone – but the tensions are too high for that.
Direction
Gilt-Leaf Ambush: Tribal Instant – Elf
This basically says to me that the tribal instincts in the Tories are like those in Labour when they used to harp on about the miners and what Thatcher was doing to them. It is difficult to see the Tories curing themselves of their petty tribalism and distinguishing themselves from the naked self-interest of Labour. Labour tripped themselves up over Margaret Beckett, but this card suggests that the Tories’ attempts to claim Labour are trying to “fix” the election by introducing PR or have appointed Bercow Speaker merely to spite them show they are walking into ambushes that Fate has left for them. This impresses very few people I know, except the most nakedly tribal among them. I have learned through bitter experience myself that to really understand government you have to stand outside your own party on occasion. Not as far outside it as John Bercow, admittedly, but such that you gain perspective on your own failings. Ironically it was tribal old Owlperson who taught me that but then again he shocked me quite a lot when we got to know each other two years ago that it helped my political self-discovery to an extent where I understand this particular situation and the consequences of tribal ambushes everywhere.
Solution
Fistful of Force: Instant
Again, the Tories need to whack forward; they can’t go back to the languid stalemate of the past few years. The “Clash” element of the card, where random elements decide what is going to happen next in the game, suggests that possibilities can be found but that their magnitude – and hence their impact – is still up for debate and may not fully depend on them.
Outcome
Skittering Monstrosity: Creature – Horror
Most living things were weakened and stunted in the ruinous aftermath of the Phyrexian invasion, but a few grew more horrid than ever.
In other words, the expenses scandal has warped things so badly that what comes of the current Conservative Party is distorted and contorted so much that its original purpose is now stunted and focussed solely on naked self-advantage rather than the government of the country in the interests of all – which the Tories, once installed (harder than it often looks) are usually quite good at. The current incarnation of the Conservative Party is showing that the Nasty Party never really went away, and that Cameron cannot control it; he is part of it himself if he cannot do so. Luckily the appearance of a new figure will kill this abomination, but for now it remains on the game-board, oozing nastiness everywhere.
Significant events – Summer
Think Twice: Instant
“Great books are meant to be read, then read again backwards or upside down!” – Ettovard, Tolarian archivist
The card’s keyword is Flashback, which hits me as a clue to what comes out of this thinking period; and then it suggests that the party has to search high and low for a clear and lasting solution. As I said, the Vodalian Mage is a Tory, but he may not be a Conservative – not at this point or in the way Conservative currently means. The party has to solve this issue – one more of leadership, direction and strategy as well as the issue of what to do with the Skittering Monstrosity – before it can progress, and this has to happen this summer to have any chance of impressing the public in the run up to an election. Happily, this is an event card, not an advice card, so it does.
Significant events – Autumn
Spore Flower: Creature – Fungus
Labour had “Spore Cloud” in its cards, but the product of that cloud belongs to the Tories’ autumn predictions. The skittering monstrosity that the party has become has gone to be replaced with a blossom of hope. The plant is still fungal, but the exhaustion in the posture of the woman in the card at least means that the party has come to rest and found its voice in a seemly manner conducive to the kind of public debate that creates a government rather than merely wins elections. Thankfully, this coincides with the return of the Vodalian Mage and confirms he is a Conservative.
