Posts archive for: 9 November, 2008
  • 9 November 2008 - ICM poll - Where now for the Brown bounce? Part 2 - The Conservatives


    Apologies for the long wait for this post but there was a power cut right after I praised David Cameron's new trailer for Tory tax policies. Stranger things have happened but the original post seems to have been lost, so therefore I know not to do that again. Originally the power company said that it would take until the early hours of tomorrow morning to get the fault fixed, but we were just buckling up to go out when things came back on, and so as not to waste the spag bol I had been in the process of cooking, we stayed at home.

    So obviously I am not allowed to praise Foxy then. Shame, because his plans to announce tax policy later this coming week are actually what people have been asking for for a while, though it doesn't seem to change the overall predictions.

    Also I am fully booked to be in Estonia/Latvia/Lithuania between Monday 24th November and Monday 8th December, so this blog will be coming to you from the Baltic States between those dates. I will be taking my mother's camera (mine is a cheapo s/h one that stopped working a number of months ago) so I will be able to upload photos and a travel diary of sorts.

    THE CONSERVATIVE PARTY

    1. External appearances of poll. STRENGTH - "A pointer towards exercising your qualities of reason, rather than to respond wiith anger, injured pride or feelings of self-importance. The lion on his own can be a very destructive force, but when feelings are brought under the jurisdiction of the mind, then something much more positive can be derived."

    The Tories have not sunk behind Labour yet but their response to this poll have been rationalisations and muted concern (apart from Louise Bagshawe, for whom complacency is not obviously a dirty word). They are apparently still holding Labour off and need to keep doing so. To do this they need to capitalise on these leads and understand that Rome was not built in a day.

    2. Internal expressions to this poll. TEMPERANCE REVERSED - "Overlooking pitfalls. Not centred, little foundation. Dispersed energy pattern."

    A very unbalanced and difficult card which suggests a lack of coherency and stability. (It fell out of the pack reversed even though all the other cards were upright.) The Tories do not seem to have the same potential for actual growth and even Tim Montgomerie at one point played down the significance of the result by pointing out that relative to pre-conference lows, Brown had still maintained part of his "bounce". Not a good omen for the Tories and an imbalance needing correction in one way or another.

    3. Obstacles. KNIGHT OF WANDS - "Dynamic male energy. If it represents a person, it would show the querent or someone with whom they are connected in some area of activity. If it represents a process, it indicates the need for a high level of energy to complete the tasks at hand."

    The Tories lack this energy level needed - as in the inverted Temperance - and need to generate it properly to turn these poll margins into reality at a general election. The lack of electoral ballast in Glenrothes was expected but still, in the words of the Telegraph, "pitiful". The Tories need to overcome this inertia or else snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

    4. Overcoming these obstacles. IV WANDS - "Welcome home! The poles are dressed for an important guest to return to the castle and that guest is to be greatly honoured. Working with other people toward a common purpose."

    The Tories overcame part of this inertia by actually beginning to put forward plans for tax cuts. I am tentatively welcoming this because it may help put some flesh on the bones of a proper manifesto. However, this is only the beginnings of a secure structure and there needs to be real progress on this front in order to stave off problems closer to the election.

    5. Direction. THE SUN - "An opportunity to plan, build, execute projects. Entering a period of sustained empowerment. Light after darkness."

    There is a sense of illumination and construction here with Cameron's team beginning to respond to criticism that they have been in danger of slipping further because of a reluctance to promote policies that would engender a more concrete public profile and maintain some of the momentum they generated during 2008.

    6. Solution. V CUPS - "Disillusionment, if you rely on the commitments of others. The need for self-reliance. Also don't focus so much on the past. Here, the figure in the card must turn around from what has been spilled and drink afresh from the cups which stand upright."

    It may however be too little too late - the negativity of the outcome cards is still there, and this belies the presence of The Sun in the "Direction" position because it means that something elsewhere has failed. Although at this point it is best not to make a mountain out of a molehill, the failure of this to create momentum is palpable and the opportunity wasted for making political capital. The Tories need to tread carefully; but I am not able to advise them directly so anything I say is not going to be taken seriously enough to avert spillage. Whether they can mop it up is another matter.

    7. Outcome in the end. III SWORDS - "A human heart pierced by three swords. Heartbreak, unless you can communicate."

    As indicated by the Four of Wands and The Sun, there is life in these tax proposals and poll to energise the Conservative Party and make sure it stays in the running and free from complacency. But, counter-intuitive to this, the end result doesn't appear to be good - why has yet to be revealed, but perhaps this policy is a damp squib, or the agenda is stolen by other crises elsewhere in the Party to turn things sour at the last moment. I would say I am happy with Cameron finally putting something forward, but the end result seems to be negative. How negative remains to be seen.

  • 9 November 2008 - ICM Poll - where now for the Brown bounce? Part 1 - LABOUR


    I did get drunk, and I did get hungover this morning. So I was excused from the Remembrance Day commemorations at the local war memorial, unfortunately. However I was there in spirit.

    The Sunday Telegraph has published an ICM poll showing the Conservatives with a 13% lead - cue the usual crowing from Louise Bagshawe (appropriate, because she like me is a Crow totem). Given the Tories are still in for a rather messy future, perhaps it is time to look more closely at both parties without confusing the issue by reading for particular events. The outcomes forecasted are if anything counter-intuitive, unless the current plans to cut taxes are a damp squib and this poll - taken on Nov 5 and 6, before the Glenrothes election result - is going to provoke complacency rather than action on all fronts.

    By the way, the betting price that I am a troll on Conservative Home is up to £5.00 as of last posting. Personally I resent that remark, because I'm a Conservative member and voter, but what is wrong with a bird's-eye perspective on things? I'd rather be considered a troll than be so blinkered and unthinking I make Mandelson look indepedent-minded. I can't help the fact that I took a disliking to Cameron the day I first saw him in the papers. I can't help the way the cards are falling for him. I come with personal references as an election campaigner from two new Tory MPs, both of whom introduced me to people at Conference 2005 as "the person who won me my seat", and John Redwood still sends me a Christmas card. What other Tory credentials can I have?

    I'm just trying to play Devil's Advocate because I think the party deserves better management, focus by its Shadow Cabinet and expression of its raison d'etre and I'm certainly NOT making The Tower up.

    This is the assessment for Labour then.

    LABOUR

    1. External appearances after this poll. THREE OF PENTACLES - "The card for studying, for learning new subjects or enhancing skills, especially through training."

    Labour are making modest progress, though the initial impact of the 13% deficit indicates that there is a lot more ground to make up. They are keeping ahead of the Tories in terms of their record on the economy, which will probably be more important at any general election than "who gets on best with Barack Obama". Still, the public perception is still that they have a long way to go to put themselves into a position where they can risk calling an election.

    2. Internal expressions after this poll. THE WHEEL OF FORTUNE - "Abundance is the keyword here, but it is directly related to your faith, your hope, your optimism. The need to think on a bigger scale, to think not just of the next project but on the next 100 projects! A person ultimately gets only what they truly expect. So let's make your expectation higher, so that we can get some bigger and better results."

    Referring to the shock of the Glenrothes result and the Wheel of Fortune turning unexpectedly in their favour, Labour believe more in their own potential than they have done for a while. A shift has happened internally such that there are now more grounds for optimism than previously. A change in internal perception from "glass half empty" to "glass half full" may improve psychological expectations and thus before long be reflected in reality.

    3. Obstacles. ACE OF PENTACLES - "A new doorway opening up for exploration, which may well be beneficial to go through and explore. In particular it refers to work opportunity."

    The need here is for concrete manifestation of the Brown bounce and, while the poll was done prior to the result in Glenrothes this manifestation is still elusive for Labour who have to be absolutely certain that more definite signs of recovery in marginal areas, particularly in England, were visible before going to a general poll. Something that needs to appear in substance before a Brown bounce can be turned into a Brown take-off.

    4. Overcoming the obstacles. SIX OF WANDS - "Victory, the time being shown here in which you enter into the city amid great fanfare, after having overcome a strong force."

    This could refer to the Glenrothes result, given that the poll was taken before the results became known. It demonstrates partial success of the needs in 3; or it could alternatively suggest that a lot of minor, temporary-seeming victories could end up coalescing into a bigger swing upwards. Brown needs to be pro-active (which it is possible to be as Prime Minister) and he needs to be opportunistic and ready to spin things in his direct favour. Confidence in the various possibilities will also pay off.

    5. Direction afterwards. THE DEVIL - "The need to develop a more positive self-image. Don't over-emphasise the problems you are faced with - look upon them as opportunities for growth. Maintain your faith and keep alive your spirit of hope."

    Brown here needs to keep up the pressure and be ruthless and daring as well as realistic about the probabilities for success following Glenrothes. He needs to be as belligerent as possible and exert control over his party, not shrinking from legitimate use of his political power. He needs to keep calm in a crisis and make sure that he doesn't get deflected by still-mediocre poll results. He also needs to maintain the momentum the economic crisis has given him.

    6. Solution. KING OF CUPS - "This card generally shows not so much a person as a situation of culmination. Thus, a certain emotional scenario has been resolved, a state of happiness is either achieved or achievable. This card portrays a man with a calm ocean behind him. The ocean represents the realm of feelings which are now becalmed."

    Brown is out of danger but now much prove himself to be useful and to be able to refloat his own prospects after the success in Glenrothes (although people point out it was a safe seat, the psychological aspects of the win against all odds make people believe that it was more of an achievement than it objectively was). He has fulfilled certain requirements and is living up to his reputation as a skilful handler of the economy - and crises in general - but to be certain of election victory he has to try and develop the situation beyond "becalmed" and push the storm that threatened him a few weeks ago back the other way.

    7. Outcome in the end. ACE OF WANDS - "A new enterprise being started. By looking at the surrounding cards we would have idea as to what."

    Brown is being counselled here to be as aggressive as possible while still remaining within ethical guidelines (which the Devil suggests, intriguingly for a man of Brown's personal probity, he is in danger of overstepping). He is still able to take credit from the response to the credit crunch and has passed the hard exam set by the electorate in Glenrothes. He needs a series of swift coups, whether economic or political in nature, to spur the agenda onwards. A new parliamentary year is about to commence, so the initiatives of this may mean he is able to improve much more markedly than recently.

    The Tories' results will follow later but I need a cup of coffee and a sandwich before going much further with this.

Email subscription

You can receive the posts of this blog by email.

RSS Feed
RSS 1.0
Posts
Comments
RSS 2.0
Posts
Comments
Atom
Posts
Comments

Footer:

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.